| Argument to the Purse |
Logical Fallacy of Argument to the Purse / Argumentum Ad Crumenam / Appeal to Poverty / Argumentum ad LazarumThe logical fallacy of argument to the purse occurs when someone reasons that how rich or poor a person is determines the soundness of their argument. Examples of the Logical Fallacy of Argument to the Purse / Argumentum Ad Crumenam / Appeal to Poverty / Argumentum ad LazarumFiddler on the roof: “When you're rich, they think you really know!” With humor it’s recognized that people do think this way, but, the way it’s put, the implication is that it is not necessarily so. Ecclesiastes: “Now there lived in that city a man poor but wise, and he saved the city by his wisdom. But nobody remembered that poor man. So I said, "Wisdom is better than strength." But the poor man's wisdom is despised, and his words are no longer heeded. The quiet words of the wise are more to be heeded than the shouts of a ruler of fools. Wisdom is better than weapons of war, but one sinner destroys much good.“ Whoever wrote Ecclesiastes knew that the poor may be wise but that people won’t recognize it. Yet, people may listen when the solution emerges to a terrible problem. There will be no recognition afterward, however.
This old saying nails it. It implies that if you are smart you will be rich. That’s just not reasonable, and there are many exceptions.
Dismissal of an argument simply based on how much money someone makes is not rational because it fails to assess the argument on its merits. 
How can we know anything about anything? That’s the real question |
Other Pages in this sectionFaulty Appeal to Authority False Attribution Pretentiousness Ad Verecundiam The Semi-Attached Figure Biased Authority Anonymous Authority Appeal to Self-Declared Authority Authority of the Select Few Invincible Authority Appeal to Celebrity Style over Substance Appeal to the Exotic Appeal to Gravity Appeal to Accomplishment Appeal to Control of Scientific Journals Control of Scientific Funding Appeal to Control of News Media Spotlight Wisdom of the Ancients Halo Effect Reverse Halo Effect / Devil Effect According to the Rules Fallacy Word Magic Recently Viewed |
