|Logical Fallacy of Marginalizing|
Logical Fallacy of Marginalizing
The logical fallacy of marginalizing is an extreme form of the bandwagon fallacy that occurs when it is implied that people holding a certain viewpoint are a fringe group and that their viewpoint is therefore false. As with all bandwagon fallacies, this one uses popular opinion (or implied popular opinion) as the measure of what is true rather than using evidence and logic.
Examples of the Logical Fallacy of Marginalizing
Bill Nye, debating Ken Ham, is using the logical fallacy of bandwagon with a particular twist known as marginalization. The very term, mainstream science implies there is a mainstream group and anyone who disagrees with what those folks say is the minority and should just fall in line with the old ideas. This censoring of disagreement within the scientific community was a difficult picture for Bill Nye to paint while still maintaining that Bill Nye’s definition of science is open to new ideas. However, Bill Nye did irrationally maintain both mutually exclusive views throughout the debate, which is the logical fallacy of internal inconsistency. He was plainly holding two mutually exclusive, conflicting, views at the same time.
Bill Nye's implication is that Ken Ham, and, perhaps a small band of his followers, are the only people in the world who believe what God is saying through the Bible. Of course, this is ad hominem since this has nothing to do with Ken Ham. People are following Christ, not Ken Ham. And the entire world can be wrong without affecting the truth one bit.
Bill is using the fallacy of misused statistics for the purpose of persuasion. Throughout the debate, Bill Nye’s main effort was to make those who follow Christ seem like the fringe of society (tactic of marginalizing), when, in fact, over 90% of Americans self-identify as Christians and about half of those take the Bible as it is written. This is both a fallacy of relevance, specifically, bandwagon (How does majority opinion affect reality?) and a fallacy of misused statistics. Since this is all by innuendo rather than direct statement, it is even less subject to challenge. So, there are two points of fallacy: Bill Nye implied that biblical Christianity is a fringe group and the atheistic/agnostic belief system is mainstream. Whether something is fringe or mainstream has no effect on reality, and a reasonable man would not have brought it up.
Last updated: Aug, 2014
Toons & Vids
Logical Fallacy of Appeal to the People / Argumentum ad populum / Bandwagon / Appeal to Common Belief / Peer Pressure
Logical Fallacy of Fake Consensus
Packing the House Fallacy
Logical Fallacy of Appeal to Self-Interest / Appeal to Desire / Appeal to Personal Interest / Homily Ad Hominem (type of)
Logical Fallacy of Marginalizing
Logical Fallacy of Appeal to Rugged Individualism / Appeal to the Minority / Authority of the Select Few
Logical Fallacy of Appeal to Common Folk / Plain Folks / Appeal to the Common Man / Argumentum Ad Populum
Logical Fallacy of Applying Time Pressure
Contrarian Argument Fallacy Abuse
Logical Fallacy of Peer Pressure
Social Conformance Fallacy
Cool Idolatry Fallacy
Logical Fallacy of Appeal to Common Practice / "Everybodyâ€™s Doing It"
Logical Fallacy of Snob Appeal / Snob Approach
Logical Fallacy of Proof by Intimidation / Argument from Intimidation
Forestalling Disagreement Fallacy
Logical Fallacy of Appeal to Patriotism
Answer to Critic
Appeal to Possibility
Argument to the Future
Love Between a Man and Woman
Righteousness & Holiness
Proof by Atheism
Scriptures About Marriage
The Reason for Rejecting Truth
Witness on the Internet
Flaky Human Reasoning
How Do You Know?
The Real Purpose of the Church
The Real Purpose of Life
From Glory to Glory
REAL Faith--What it IS & IS NOT
REAL Love--What it IS & IS NOT
How to be Led by God
How to Witness
Wisdom: Righteousness & Reality
Holiness & Mind/Soul
Redemption: Free From Sin
Stories Versus Revelation
Circular Reasoning-Who is Guilty?
How Can We Know Anything?
Mind Designed to Relate to God
Answers for the Confused
Fossil Record Says: "Creation"
Avoid These Pitfalls
Public School's Religion
Public School Failures