|Grammatical Presupposition / Assumptive Language|
Whenever a logical fallacy is committed, the fallacy has its roots in Agrippa's trilemma. All human thought (without Divine revelation) is based on one of three unhappy possibilities. These three possibilities are infinite regression, circular reasoning, or axiomatic thinking. This is known as Agrippa's trilemma. Some have claimed that only logic and math can be known; however, that is not true. Without Divine revelation, neither logic nor math can be known. Science is limited only to pragmatic thinking because of the weakness of human reasoning, which is known as Agrippa's trilemma. Grammatical presupposition, a form of axiomatic thinking, is one of these three unhappy possibilities.
The logical fallacy of grammatical presupposition occurs when presuppositions are hidden in language. Words and phrases such as "when," "whenever," "how," "why," "obviously," or "where" become tools to insert hidden presuppositions.
Examples of Grammatical Presupposition
This phrase has three nested presuppositions hidden in the words: "obviously," "when," and "we discovered." This is irrational and one of the hypnotic methods that are used on you. It works by overloading your ability to consciously process information and to attempt to slip ideas into your innermost mind without your awareness.
"I just want to remind us all” This is a grammatical presupposition inserted into a sentence. If Bill is "reminding" us, then there is no need to question anything that he says, since he is merely reminding us of what we already know. Also notice the strange grammar again. This is a very subtle technique that he is using to continue to build his "the world against Ken Ham" argument, which is an extreme form of bandwagon fallacy.
“there are billions of people in the world who are deeply religious, who get enriched by the wonderful sense of community by their religion.” This is a logical fallacy of understatement. Bill Nye is implying that the purpose of the church is to get enriched by the wonderful sense of community. The fact is that the purpose of the church is to so come to know Christ that we becomes transformed into His same image from glory to glory by the Spirit of the Lord. And there is much more to it than that. When someone knows nothing about a subject, it would be helpful if they were to avoid speaking as an expert on the subject.
“these same people do not embrace the ‘extraordinary’ view that the Earth is ‘somehow’ only 6,000 years old. That is unique.” Bill Nye is using the logical fallacy of Argumentum Ad Lapidem, with the word, "extraordinary," implying that a belief is absurd without proving it to be absurd. Here Bill Nye also employs the logical fallacies of marginalizing,bandwagon, and creating a false impression to manipulate the minds of the audience to his political view. Bill Nye also uses the logical fallacy of the outright lie, saying, “the extraordinary view that the Earth is ‘somehow’ only 6,000 years old. That is unique.” This statement is made to marginalize, but it is clearly false. The belief that the Earth is 6,000 years old is shared by about half (46%) of all Americans. So this lie was perpetrated to activate the logical fallacy of bandwagon, but how many people believe something can have no possible impact on what reality is. Perhaps Bill is saying that anyone who disagrees with him is holding an extraordinary view.
Bill Nye is also lumping unlike things as if they were one thing, which is the logical fallacy of faulty analogy. The fact is that Atheism is a religion, but Atheists don’t want it classified as a religion, so they resort to using the definist fallacy by defining religion in a way that helpful in persuading the audience to believe the conclusion but doesn’t really support the conclusion. They define the word, religion, in a way that includes everyone but themselves. However, their belief in not God or belief that no one can know God is based on vapor, made up stuff. It is held on make-believe faith. And, atheists do “get enriched by the wonderful sense of community by their religion.” Atheism is a philosophy about God. It is a belief that God doesn’t exist. Agnosticism is a belief that no one can know anything about God or spiritual things. Both are irrational in many ways, but they are religions. The big-bang-billions-of-years-molecules-to-man story is a religious doctrine of Atheism, and most Agnostics believe it as well. Lumping followers of Christ in with all religions misses the point. Jesus Christ is the Son of God. All things came into existence by Him and without Him nothing came into existence. We know this by revelation. The Holy Spirit Himself tells us this. This makes Jesus Christ unique and not to be lumped in with any religions. Some people make the following of Jesus Christ into a religion, and the apostle, James, wrote that true religion is this: caring for widows and orphans. James, however, had a completely different definition of religion from Bill Nye.
Last updated: Sep, 2014
Toons & Vids
Logical Fallacy of Ipse dixit /Just Because Fallacy / Trust Me / Mother Knows Best Fallacy / Because I Said So / You'll See
Logical Fallacy of Unsupported Assertion / Alleged Certainty / Appeal to Common Sense / Bare Assertion Fallacy / Unprovable Statement / Groundless Claim
Secret Knowledge Fallacy
Autistic Certainty Fallacy
Logical Fallacy of Assertion Contrary to Fact / Counterfactual Fallacy / Lie / Untruth
Big Lie Technique / Staying on Message
Logical Fallacy of the Outright Lie / Total Lie
Logical Fallacy of the Bold-Faced Lie / Bald-Faced Lie
Appeal to Confidence
Logical Fallacy of Hypothesis Contrary to Fact / Argumentum Ad Speculum / speculative fallacy /
Logical Fallacy of False Prophecy
Argument to the Future / Escape to the Future
Escape Via Ignorance
Logical Fallacy of Argumentum Ex Culo
Logical Fallacy of Blind Obedience / Blind Authority / Team Player
Logical Fallacy of False Accusation / Finding a Fault Where None Exists / False Conflict / False Error
Argument from Omniscience
Logical Fallacy of Universal Negative
As Far As Anyone Knows Fallacy
Proving a Negative Fallacy / Negative Proof Fallacy
Claim of Unknowables Fallacy
The Logical Fallacy of Presupposition/Assumptive Thinking
Irrelevant Purpose Fallacy
Thompson Invisibility Syndrome
Logical Fallacy of Presumption
Grammatical Presupposition / Assumptive Language
Floating Abstraction Fallacy
Logical Fallacy of Proof by Implied Unsupported Assertion / Implied Lie
Spiritual Fallacy / Spiritual Excuse
I Wish I Had a Magic Wand Fallacy / Feigned Powerlessness
Logical Fallacy of False Open-Mindedness
Answer to Critic
Appeal to Possibility
Argument to the Future
Love Between a Man and Woman
Righteousness & Holiness
Proof by Atheism
Scriptures About Marriage
The Reason for Rejecting Truth
Witness on the Internet
Flaky Human Reasoning
How Do You Know?
The Real Purpose of the Church
The Real Purpose of Life
From Glory to Glory
REAL Faith--What it IS & IS NOT
REAL Love--What it IS & IS NOT
How to be Led by God
How to Witness
Wisdom: Righteousness & Reality
Holiness & Mind/Soul
Redemption: Free From Sin
Stories Versus Revelation
Circular Reasoning-Who is Guilty?
How Can We Know Anything?
Mind Designed to Relate to God
Answers for the Confused
Fossil Record Says: "Creation"
Avoid These Pitfalls
Public School's Religion
Public School Failures