|This is a Very Common Challenge--The Question: If God is good, and God created everything, then why is there evil?|
If you have not read Stories Versus Truth, you may want to read that before reading this.
This particular question assumes moral superiority over God, doesn't it? See also Why think that God should define goodness?
Yet, if Atheism (or many other religious views) were true, how could you define good? Many Hindus, for example, openly admit that they believe that there is no good, evil, right, wrong, truth, or error. A consistent Atheist or Agnostic would have to say the same. For those who believe that all is random, there is no rational way to claim that one way of acting is righteous and another way of acting is unrighteous. Some of them do claim that there is good and evil, but they are being inconsistent and irrational by making such a claim while also claiming that everything happens by random chance (that is, that there is no God). For those who claim that there is a god (small g) but that nothing can be known about this god, they would have no way of discerning what is good or evil either.
It is a fact that the unbeliever must be irrational in defining good. They must be arbitrary, which is irrational. They have no absolute standard. If they did, what would it be? Only the follower of Christ has an absolute standard that is both internally and externally consistent. That standard is that which is revealed by God Himself. The standard is received by revelation in real time from the throne of God.
The fact is that, without the God of the Bible, there can be no objective good or evil. God defines good and evil. The purpose of asking the unbeliever to test his or her logical basis for judging right and wrong is to help the unbeliever to realize that their question borrows a viewpoint that can only logically belong to a Christian.
Interestingly, logic cannot exist outside of the God of the Bible either. There is no reason for the law of noncontradiction, for instance, to exist in the worldview of the unbeliever. For the Christian, the law of noncontradiction is just a revelation of the nature of God. Many unbelieving religions actually reject the law of noncontradiction, which is illogical and can easily be shown to be wrong.
The reason those who follow Christ believe is not based on physical evidence or human argument, though the observable physical evidence supports God's existence and His Truth without the mental gymnastics that the Atheists and Evolutionists find themselves tangled in. It is based in the power of God. Faith comes by hearing and hearing by the word (utterance) of God. God speaks. God speaks to every person. Whoever will listen receives the faith that is of God. This is a supernatural belief that is not human-generated. It is a gift. That faith is the belief that what God has said is true. Before a person is born again, there is a history of hearing God's voice. No one can come to Christ unless the Father draws him or her. A person is born again the moment that he or she hears God's voice and receives faith to believe in Jesus as Savior from sin. In the same way, it is God who speaks and says that the Bible is the Word of God without error. When we hear His voice, then His faith comes, the supernatural belief that the Bible is the Word of God without error. Once God opens our eyes, we see that the Bible is the only source that is both internally and externally consistent. We cannot possibly believe unless we are having an active interaction with our Maker. Some Christians are not aware enough of their own experience to know this. That's why we have all the previously-mentioned reasons for believing the Bible as the Word of God. (some caveats about hearing God's Voice)
Interestingly, explanation given in the previous paragraph does not depend on circular reasoning or poor logic. It depends on God. This is the kind of faith that is what is really operating. It is based on revelation. Now, a naturalist will attack the whole idea of revelation claiming that revelation cannot be verified.
Last updated: Nov, 2013
Is God responsible for abortions, murders, starvation, rapes, infant deaths, and sin?
Toons & Vids
How Can We Know Anything About Anything?
Is it a Sin to Drink Alcohol in Moderation?
Does Evil Exist?
Lies Based on Nothing Versus Truth Based on Revelation
Revelational Apologetics versus Presuppositional Apologetics
This is a Very Common Challenge--The Question: If God is good, and God created everything, then why is there evil?
What Do You Say If They Reject Christ but Just Want to Argue?
All Paths Lead to God ??
Is it true that once you are born again it is impossible that you could sin?
Challenge: Why does God have to judge sin. Sin isn't such a bad thing. Why can't we all just do what we want?
Accusation: Churches Accused of Being Criminal Organizations Run by Pedophiles
What about all the Shortcomings of the Church?
This Scoffer's Question is as Follows: Is Objective Morality a Law the God Must Obey, or Does God Arbitrarily Apply a Morality as a Fiat?
All things are relative
Blind Faith and Other Misunderstandings About What Faith Is
Questions and Challenges About Salvation
Questions About Sin
Why does God need money?
Does Belief in Christ and Belief that God Reveals Through the Bible Require Circular Reasoning?
Why did God stop talking to people as He talked to them in the Old Testament times?
We Don't Need God?? Really????
Religion seems to be all about
Someone thinks that God had a wife in one older version of the bible and she got eliminated in a newer version
Racism And Understanding The Only Two Races That Exist.
Assertion: I believe in a higher power that designed all of this; however I have a hard time with the Bible and religion
Pointing Out the Closed Mind
Christians Fall Away
This Challenge Asks the Question: Why think that God should define goodness?
You may hear someone say that Jesus' story is not unique
Questions and Answers: What would you say to someone who doesn't want to repent because he thinks life will become dull and boring?
Some people think that prayer does not work. Some people don't understand what prayer is or how it works.
Scoffer's Queston: If Jesus makes so much difference personally, why does He not make a difference in society?
Questions and Answers: What makes you think that only your view of Jesus is accurate?
Hitler was a Roman Catholic
Questions and Answers: God knew everything before he created the heavens and the earth, so why did God make people who he knew in advance would turn on him and go to hell?
Why is it that God created Adam from dirt and then had to use a rib to create Eve?
Why does it say in "our image"?
God's Foreknowledge Eliminates Free Will
Life's Toughest Questions - Ravi Zacharias
Why don't Jews believe in Jesus
Answer to Critic
Appeal to Possibility
Argument to the Future
Love Between a Man and Woman
Righteousness & Holiness
Proof by Atheism
Scriptures About Marriage
The Reason for Rejecting Truth
Witness on the Internet
Flaky Human Reasoning
How Do You Know?
The Real Purpose of the Church
The Real Purpose of Life
From Glory to Glory
REAL Faith--What it IS & IS NOT
REAL Love--What it IS & IS NOT
How to be Led by God
How to Witness
Wisdom: Righteousness & Reality
Holiness & Mind/Soul
Redemption: Free From Sin
Stories Versus Revelation
Circular Reasoning-Who is Guilty?
How Can We Know Anything?
Mind Designed to Relate to God
Answers for the Confused
Fossil Record Says: "Creation"
Avoid These Pitfalls
Public School's Religion
Public School Failures