|Tactic of Politicking|
Tactic of Politicking
The tactic of politicking occurs when political games are played to bring support from a larger population than those involved in the discussion. The problem is that tricks and deceptions are used to persuade rather than open-minded exploration of the truth and the reasons to believe the truth. Other logical fallacies are usually involved, especially appeal to ridicule.
Examples of the Tactic of Politicking
Continuing the fallacies of marginalization, ad hominem, and bandwagon, Bill Nye misstated the debate topic. The question tonight had just been repeated by the debate moderator as: “Is creation a viable model of origins?” This has nothing to do with Ken Ham. However, fallacies are used because they are effective in manipulating people’s minds. Bill Nye was obviously playing to the crowd for political purposes (politicking). Of course, the actual topic would require Bill Nye to show that creation of the Universe by the Creator God is impossible, could not possibly have happened. Viable means possible or workable. There is nothing that is observed using the scientific method that in any way conflicts with divine, supernatural creation. So, as you will see, Bill Nye had to resort to tricks and fallacies to push his political agenda.
"Kentucky voters, voters who might be watching online, in places like Texas, Tennessee, Oklahoma, Kansas, please," Bill Nye now reveals his real purpose as being political. He is looking for laws to help him with the tactic of message control. He doesn't want real discussion of this issue to be allowed, especially not in the schools. This is about message control and politicking.
"you don’t want to raise a generation of science students who don’t understand how we know our place in the Cosmos, our place in space, who don’t understand natural law. We need to innovate to keep the United States where it is in the world." Bill Nye is right. We don’t want to raise a generation of science students who don’t understand how we know our place in the Cosmos, our place in space, who don’t understand natural law. It is not a logical fallacy to use innuendo, but it can make it more difficult to tell if someone is being irrational. To use the logical fallacy of proof by repetition is irrational, however. Yet it works on some people. Bill Nye previously used this innuendo against what God says. Ken Ham showed videos of recognized scientists who are biblical creationists. (Interestingly, some Atheist websites have posted that this was an example of appeal to authority on the part of Ken Ham. It was not, because Ken was not proving that Creation was true using authority. Ken was showing that Bill Nye's claim that "no real scientists are creationists" was a false claim.) Then, Bill Nye repeated his innuendo. And, he continued to repeat this innuendo throughout the debate. See this excellent cartoon. We have raised several generations now that don't understand their place in the cosmos. They don't know they are children of God and that life has purpose and meaning. They have been taught naturalism, and the results can be seen in the coarsening of the society. Atheists have made headway, and we have seen atheist students going into schools killing other students to enforce natural selection--in their own words. With the direction set by an education system that teaches the precepts of atheism, the United States is heading toward the same place that every country that turns away from God goes. We see it in the lack of morals. We see it in the spread of incurable diseases. We see it in the attacks by enemies that are being allowed against this country. And we know, by revelation which He clearly gives through Scripture, that this is how God works. We are seeing it unfold before our eyes. That is a prediction. If we continue in the Secular Humanist direction, the nation will fail. If we turn toward Christ, the nation will be restored.
Bill Nye is using the logical fallacy of self-refutation, of conflicting conditions, in that his argument is internally inconsistent. He claims that the United States has made all these advances in the past, a past that used the Bible as a textbook in the schools, a past that had leaders who proclaimed Jesus Christ as Lord, a past in which most Americans would not have questioned the Bible's inerrancy. Then, he claims that if we don't stop doing this, the technical advances will stop. In fact, nearly every major branch of science was started by a young-Earth creationist. So, Bill Nye's contention destroys itself.
Last updated: Sep, 2014
Toons & Vids
Tactic of Message Control / Subversion
Sanctioning the Devil Fallacy / Avoiding Sanctioning the Devil
Tactic of Dominating the Conversation
Tactic of Spamming
The Tactic of Quenching
The Tactic of Propaganda
Tactic of Subversion
Tactic of Needling
Tactic of Infiltration / Hostile Takeover
The Tactic of Intimidation
Tactic of Argument by Question
Tactic of Argument by Rhetorical Question
The Tactic of Discrimination
Tactic of Projecting a Popular Image
Tactic of Storytelling
The Tactic of Misreporting in Mass Media
Tactic of Association
Tactic of Suggestion
Tactic of Neuro Linguistic Programming
Tactic of Fear Mongering / Scare Tactics
Tactic of Hate Mongering
Tactic of Stonewalling
Tactic of Politicking
Tactic of Failure To State / Arguing for a Position While Insisting that there is No Position / "Prove Your Belief, BUT My Belief Is Not Disclosed"
Tactic of Lobbying
The Tactic of Brainwashing
Tactic of Tossing the Elephant / Throwing Mud at the Wall to See What Will Stick / Shotgun Argument
Tactic of Debate Rather Than Trying to Find the Truth / Debate Mindset
Tactic of Obtuseness / Willful Ignorance / Willed Ignorance
Logical Fallacy of Refusing to Look at Evidence
Tactic of Pious Fraud / The Ends Justify the Means Fallacy
Tactic of Demanding Impossible Condition
Tactic of Self-Fulfilling Prophecy
Self-Sealing Argument Fallacy
God Wildcard Fallacy
Science Wildcard Fallacy
Tactic of Moving the Overton Window / Logical Fallace of "We Have to Do Something"
Tactic of Monopolizing the Conversation / Filibustering
Tactic of NIGY / Now I've Got You
Fait Accompli Tactic / Easier Asking Forgiveness than Permission
Tactic of Spin Doctoring
Answer to Critic
Appeal to Possibility
Argument to the Future
Love Between a Man and Woman
Righteousness & Holiness
Proof by Atheism
Scriptures About Marriage
The Reason for Rejecting Truth
Witness on the Internet
Flaky Human Reasoning
How Do You Know?
The Real Purpose of the Church
The Real Purpose of Life
From Glory to Glory
REAL Faith--What it IS & IS NOT
REAL Love--What it IS & IS NOT
How to be Led by God
How to Witness
Wisdom: Righteousness & Reality
Holiness & Mind/Soul
Redemption: Free From Sin
Stories Versus Revelation
Circular Reasoning-Who is Guilty?
How Can We Know Anything?
Mind Designed to Relate to God
Answers for the Confused
Fossil Record Says: "Creation"
Avoid These Pitfalls
Public School's Religion
Public School Failures